Townsend Letter for Doctors and Patients, Dec, 2002 by
Tim Batchelder
Royal jelly is perhaps more than
any other dietary supplement one of controversy. With a brief
history of use and scant biochemical studies it appears to be
an unlikely contender in the supplement scene. Yet, its popularity
remains high and anecdotal reports of energy enhancement abound.
However, recently, a novel mechanism of liver support has emerged
that supports at least some of its traditional uses. In this article
I will outline some of this emerging research on this supplement
based on recent product development work I conducted for a specialized
bee product company.
Traditional Use
Apitherapy is becoming increasingly popular in China and there
are more and more institutes that use bee products in their pharmaceutical
regimen (such as Xi'an of Shanxi, Lianyungang of Zhenjiang
and Nanjing of Jiangsu). Arthritis is treated by bee stings, which
have also been used recently for muscular dystrophy in the US.
Other bee products used for medicine include honey, propolis,
and royal jelly and is very popular
among "intellectuals" (professors, researchers, etc).
Royal Jelly was highly valued by Chinese monarchs as a way to
increase longevity and sexual power. Royal jelly has been used
in Traditional Chinese Medicine for 70-80 years. It is used for
conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, hypertension, diabetes,
chronic hepatitis, duodenal ulcer, menstrual problems, uterine
bleeding and infertility, fatigue, weakness, poor nutrition, leucopenia,
and cancer therapy support. Shen Nong's Herbal Classic (100-200
BC) explains that bee products "treat evil influence, supplement
the insufficiency in the five visceras, help qi and mend the heart."
They also relieve pain and detoxify, "get rid of a
hundred diseases," can be "mixed with hundreds of
medicines," and "strengthen the will and tighten the body,
make people young and prolong life." The herbal compendium
Materia Medica by Li Shishen written during the Ming Dynasty
states that bee products "are sweet and mild, so that they
can detoxify; soft so that they can soften and moisten; slow
for taking it easy." As a result they are considered good
for "relieving heart pain, stomach pain, sore muscles, and
ulcers" and "can bring peace to the heart and can add
harmony to hundreds of medicines."
In the Materia Medica royal jelly
is considered a tonic for yin deficiency (and general deficiencies)
like ginseng, fo-ti, dang qui, astragalus, common jujube and lycium
fruit. Royal jelly is combined with these and other herbs. In
Traditional Chinese Medicine energy or Qi is thought to flow from
or be regulated by the liver, which is significant biologically
given the recent research on royal jelly's regenerative effects
on the liver described below. Case studies from Japan document
its traditional and popular use and effectiveness for fatigue
(Inoue 1986). Japanese office workers consume royal jelly in genki
drinks, which are energizing tonics. In addition, royal jelly
has been used in Eastern European countries as an adaptogen (broadly
defined as an agent that increases strength, endurance and resistance
to stress). (Wagner et al. 1984)
Other Insect Medicines
Other insects and insect products are widely used in
traditional medicine. In Chinese medicine there were 21
insects used in medicine according to the Shennong
Pharmacopoeia (100-200AD) which has since been enlarged to
include 73 insects in Compendium Materia Media published in
1578. Chinese galls (Wubeizi) are used for sores and are
produced by an aphid on Chinese sumac (Chou Io, 1990). One
of the most pricey insect medicines is Dong Chong Tsia Tsiao
(winter caterpillar summer grass) which is a caterpillar
fungus that consists of larvae of Hepialus armoricanus
infected with a entomopathogenic fungus Cordyceps sinensis
that costs $700 a kilo in China wholesale! (Steinkraus and
Whitefield, 1994). These are now being artificially
cultivated.
Legend has it that this fungus has effects like ginseng
and also restores impotence, shortness of breath, lung
dysfunction and pain. The egg cases of praying mantis and
blister beetles as well as cicada exuvia (molts) from trees
(which cure scrofula and ulcers) are hot commodities as
well. Silkworm frass treats diarrhea and cockroaches stop
bleeding and heal bone fractures and swelling. One village
of extremely long lived people who live beyond age 90 like
to fry copious amounts of ants which they credit to their
longevity. The main herbal medicine for hepatitis B (Mayi
Yigan Ning) contains ants and works in 60% of cases which is
twice as effective as interferon. You can also find many
wines and tonics made with ants.
Origin and Production
Royal jelly is a white substance secreted by the pharyngeal
glands of worker honeybees (family Apidae) for the queen bee
who survives upon it her whole life. The queen's life-span
is many times as long as worker bees, up to several years,
and she develops to twice the size of worker bees and
drones. In contrast, worker bees and drones do not consume
royal jelly and live much shorter lives. Worker and queen
are genetically identical which suggests the difference in
their lifespan and other developmental factors is completely
dietary and owed to the royal jelly.
Depending on environmental factors such as season,
geography and climate, the composition of royal jelly can
vary somewhat but usually consists of roughly 15% protein,
15% sugars, 6% fats, with the rest being water (60%) and
some minerals, vitamins, and free amino acids. (FAQ data
1996) Fresh royal jelly (non-freeze dried) appears to be the
most biologically active form (Salama 1977). One marker
compound, 57 kDa protein, is especially sensitive to heat
thus it is essential that royal jelly not be heated at any
time in order to preserve its activity.
Laboratory/Clinical Evidence
One of the most important aspects of royal jelly's health
benefits is its effects on the liver. Royal jelly appears to
stimulate growth (Kato et al., 1988, Watanabe et al. 1998)
particularly among liver cells (Kamakura et al. 2001). In
particular a protein called 57 kDa appears to be responsible
for this effect. Since the liver needs to regenerate
constantly to replace cells that have been damaged by
toxins, this helps to optimize liver function for
detoxification and energy production, supporting traditional
use in Traditional Chinese Medicine. It also seems to
support glycogen restoration and decrease accumulation of
waste products such as lactate and ammonia which cause
fatigue (Kamakura et al. 2001). In addition it increases
oxygen use and oxidative phosphorylation in the liver (Vittek
1995) as well as oxygen uptake in the brain (Uzbekova 1968).
High 002 levels and low 02 levels cause weakness and fatigue
(Vittek 1995). The queen uses more oxygen than worker bees
which explains the need for this effect (Rembold 1965).
Royal jelly appears to increase muscle power, vital
capacity, respiratory function and energy levels (Bertuglia
1970). It improves appetite and strength and increases body
weight in cases of malnutrition, underweight, depression,
and anorexia (Fossati 1972). Some evidence documents
feelings of mental wellbeing in older people who use royal
jelly (Iannuzzi 1990).
Royal jelly works to increase feelings of wellbeing in
patients with tuberculosis (Borgia 1984) and helps the
cardiovascular system due to its vaso-dilative (Shinoda et
al., 1978) and hypo-tensive effects (Townsend et al. 1961;
Tamura et al., 1987). Royal jelly may also lower cholesterol
and general blood lipids (Kaczor et al., 1962; Makarova,
1969; Vittek, 1995). Other research suggests it causes
feelings of "eurphoria," wellbeing, increased strength and
appetite in patients with heart conditions (Cho 1977). Due
to all these effects it may help prevent atherosclerosis (Vittek
1995) The way royal jelly works to lower cholesterol is by
binding with it in the GI tract due to the presence of
phytosterols such as Bsisterol (Makarove 1969, Madar et al.
1965, Shinoda et al. 1978).
Royal jelly is also able to support optimal blood sugar
levels by assisting in the oxidation of glucose in body fats
for energy due to an insulin effect since insulin like
peptides, are found in royal jelly (Kramer 1977, Kramer
1982). Furthermore, bee insulin is very similar to mammalian
insulin (O'Connor 1985). High levels of magnesium in royal
jelly may also reduce oxygen consumption and blood lactate
(as shown in swimmers) and may also work to increase
feelings of energy in patients with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
(Campbell et al. 1991).
Royal jelly contains a variety of B vitamins and one of
them --pantothenic acid -- stimulates the adrenal glands and
increases production of adrenal hormones. The pantothenic
acid content (B5) of royal jelly is the highest of any known
source (FAO data 1996). In humans, pantothenic acid is
converted to coenzyme A which helps the body metabolize fats
and carbohydrates. Again, we see convincing biochemical
support of its use for energy in TCM. Royal jelly also
contains testosterone which may help increase strength (Vittek
et al. 1982).
Royal jelly works to prevent injury to tissues, control
inflammation and reduce the bacterial load on the body --
all of which assist in maintaining energy. It works to
decrease inflammation and increase wound healing (Fujii et
al. 1990) due to the presence of an antibacterial peptide
called royalisin (Fujiwara et al., 1990). It also prevents
microbial growth due to the presence of a fatty acid called
10HDA (Blum 1959) and stimulates antibody production (Sver
et al. 1987). By supporting proper immune function it
prevents allergic reactions and histamine release (Oka et
al. 2001) and increases levels of nitric oxide which reduces
inflammation and improves cardiovascular function. Finally,
its ability to inhibit capillary permeability explains its
anti-inflammatory and tissue-healing ability (Fujii et al.
1990).
Conclusion
As can be seen from the above analysis, royal jelly is far
from a "snake oil" supplement as many contend and contains a
diversity of rich, bio-active compounds that we are only now
beginning to understand at a chemical level. Biochemical
research is supporting its recent history of traditional
use. In general, bee products are emerging as important
contenders in the natural products arena due their wide
variety of health benefits, prevalence, traditional use, and
appealing aesthetic properties as medicinal foods.